After Slice B1's Berufung unification (mig 134), the picker exposed
five appeal targets but only three carried rules. Schadensbemessung and
Bucheinsicht returned empty timelines.
m's 2026-05-26 decision (#134): R.224 is uniform across substantive
R.118 decisions, and R.220.2 / R.224.2.b / R.235.2 / R.237 / R.238.2 are
uniform across the orders they appeal — so the existing merits-track
and order-track rules can carry the missing targets via a non-destructive
applies_to_target extension.
Audit of live `paliad.deadline_rules` for upc.apl.unified (proceeding_type_id=160):
- 7 endentscheidung rules → extend with 'schadensbemessung'
- 7 anordnung rules → extend with 'bucheinsicht'
- 2 kostenentscheidung rules — untouched (distinct leave-to-appeal track)
Migration:
- set_config('paliad.audit_reason', …) at top of UP and DOWN — required
by the mig 079 deadline_rule_audit_trigger on every UPDATE.
- Audit-first DO block lists every row to be touched (pre/post state)
and RAISE EXCEPTIONs on pre-condition drift (missing proceeding_type,
wrong rule counts, partial-run carry-over of the new targets).
- Two narrow UPDATEs keyed off upc.apl.unified + existing target +
absence of new target.
- Post-sanity asserts schad=7, buch=7, end=7, anord=7, cost=2 — hard
RAISE EXCEPTION on any drift.
- DOWN strips both new targets via array_remove with the same WHERE.
- No deadline_rules.updated_at writes; column exists but the migration
is single-purpose and leaves it as-is.
Dry-run via Supabase MCP confirmed:
- UP yields {schad:7, buch:7, end:7, anord:7, cost:2} on prod.
- DOWN restores {schad:0, buch:0, end:7, anord:7, cost:2}.
- DB returned to pre-state; the real golang-migrate boot path will
apply 138 cleanly at next deploy.
Version bump 137→138: cronus's mig 137 (proceeding_role_labels, #132)
merged to main while this branch was in flight. Rebased onto current
main, renamed files, rewrote all "mig 137" references inside the SQL +
test code.
Test:
- lookup_events_test.go: the schadensbemessung empty-result assertion
becomes the inverse (rules expected). Adds a parallel bucheinsicht
assertion. Same anchor-row shape check as the existing endentscheidung
case (DepthFromAnchor=1, target ∈ AppliesToTarget, proceeding_type
= upc.apl.unified).
- `go test ./...` green post-rebase, including pkg/litigationplanner/
appeal_target_label_test.go added by cronus's mig 137.
Refs: m/paliad#134, t-paliad-303.
Lessons applied from mig 134 hotfixes: audit_reason set_config, no
updated_at writes, audit live DB before drafting, RAISE EXCEPTION on
integrity violations.
t-paliad-302 / m/paliad#133. Surface each event card's rule duration
("2 Mo. nach") on /tools/verfahrensablauf — by default as a hover
tooltip on the date span, and optionally inline via a new
"Dauern anzeigen" header toggle (localStorage key
paliad.verfahrensablauf.durations-show).
The issue scoped this as pure-frontend on the assumption that the
duration fields were already on the /api/tools/fristenrechner payload.
They were not: lp.TimelineEntry exposed only the computed dueDate, not
the rule's (duration_value, duration_unit, timing) tuple. Added these
as three additive optional fields and populated them in both engine
emission sites (Calculate + CalculateByTriggerEvent) from the rule
row directly. Source values are the base rule fields, not the
post-alt-swap arithmetic — the tooltip reads as a property of the
rule rather than a recap of which branch fired.
Frontend wiring:
- formatDurationLabel() in verfahrensablauf-core builds the
"<value> <unit> <timing>" string from the existing
deadlines.event.unit.<unit>.{one,many} + deadlines.event.timing.*
i18n keys, reused from /tools/fristenrechner's event-mode renderer.
- deadlineCardHtml attaches the label as title= on the date span
(hover, default) and, when CardOpts.showDurations is on, emits an
inline <span class="timeline-duration"> in the meta row.
- Court-set / zero-duration rules (trigger event, hearings) skip the
affordance — durationValue <= 0 short-circuits in
formatDurationLabel.
- Toggle persisted in localStorage under
paliad.verfahrensablauf.durations-show, default off; sits next to
the existing "Hinweise anzeigen" toggle.
bun run build clean, go test ./pkg/litigationplanner/... and
./internal/... clean, bun test src/client/views clean (89/89).
Two bugs from the Slice B1 Berufung rollout, one fix surface:
Bug A — duplicate side selectors collapse into ONE proactive-side
picker with per-proceeding role labels. The Verfahrensablauf used to
show both ?side= (Klägerseite/Beklagtenseite) AND ?appellant= (same
labels in case-form) on the Berufung tile. Now: one side picker, with
labels that swap to Berufungskläger/Berufungsbeklagter on the unified
upc.apl.unified tile (and Antragsteller/Antragsgegner Nichtigkeit on
upc.rev.cfi, Einsprechende(r)/Patentinhaber(in) on epa.opp.*).
Bug B — 'Auslösendes Ereignis' label derives from appeal_target on
the unified Berufung tile (5 target-specific strings) instead of the
proceeding's own trigger_event_label. Endentscheidung (R.118) /
Kostenentscheidung / Anordnung / Entscheidung im
Schadensbemessungsverfahren / Anordnung der Bucheinsicht.
Migration 137 (additive, no triggers on proceeding_types — verified
via mcp__supabase__execute_sql before drafting; no updated_at on the
table — lesson from mig 134 HOTFIX 3; no audit_reason setup needed):
- ADD COLUMN role_proactive_label_de (text NULL)
- ADD COLUMN role_proactive_label_en (text NULL)
- ADD COLUMN role_reactive_label_de (text NULL)
- ADD COLUMN role_reactive_label_en (text NULL)
- Audit-first DO block lists the rows the UPDATE will touch.
- Backfill 4 proceedings (upc.apl.unified + upc.rev.cfi +
epa.opp.opd + epa.opp.boa); every other proceeding stays NULL
and the renderer falls back to default labels.
- Down drops the 4 columns.
Package additions (pkg/litigationplanner):
- ProceedingType gains 4 *string fields (RoleProactive/Reactive
LabelDE/EN) — db tags match the new columns; existing scans pick
them up via the proceedingTypeColumns extension.
- TriggerEventLabelForAppealTarget(target, lang) — Go-side map of
the 5 appeal-target slugs to their DE/EN trigger-event labels.
Empty result on unknown target signals "fall back to proceeding's
own trigger_event_label".
- Engine override: when CalcOptions.AppealTarget is set, the
resulting Timeline.TriggerEventLabel/EN are replaced from the
per-target map.
Frontend:
- Removed #appellant-row div (was a separate 3-radio selector
duplicating side).
- Dropped ?appellant= URL state + the change handler + the init
readback. The engine still consumes "appellant" — sourced from
currentSide for role-swap proceedings; null otherwise.
- applyRoleLabels(proceedingType) swaps the side-row radio labels
from a hardcoded ROLE_LABELS map mirroring mig 137's backfill.
Falls back to deadlines.side.claimant/defendant i18n keys for
proceedings without overrides.
- syncTriggerEventLabel reads data.triggerEventLabel from the calc
response — which the engine override now sets per appeal_target,
so no client-side mapping needed.
- i18n cleanup: removed orphan deadlines.appellant.* keys (label /
claimant / defendant / none) in both DE + EN.
Tests:
- pkg/litigationplanner/appeal_target_label_test.go pins the 5×2
label matrix + a coverage test that fails if a new entry in
AppealTargets is added without populating the label switch.
Acceptance:
- go build + go test all green (incl. new lp test).
- bun run build clean (i18n codegen drops 4 keys, regenerates).
- Live-DB audit before drafting confirmed: 4 target columns don't
exist on proceeding_types, zero triggers on the table, exact
column inventory matches the design.
paliad.proceeding_types has no updated_at column. Removing the
UPDATE ... SET ..., updated_at = now() clause from both up and down
migrations. Third bug in cronus's Slice B1 mig 134 — production
still down.
Verified columns on paliad.proceeding_types via prod-snapshot.sql:
id, code, name, description, jurisdiction, category, default_color,
sort_order, is_active, name_en, display_order, trigger_event_label_de,
trigger_event_label_en, appeal_target (added by this mig).
Refs t-paliad-292, m/paliad#124. No new issue filed — single-line
emergency fix during head's incident response.
Mig 134's step 4 UPDATEs paliad.deadline_rules to reassign 16 rules
to the unified upc.apl.unified proceeding_type. The mig-079 audit
trigger requires set_config('paliad.audit_reason', …, true) before
any mutation — mig 134 missed it, causing the migration runner to
abort with P0001 "audit reason required for UPDATE" on every boot
after #130 landed.
Adds the canonical set_config call at the top of both up + down,
matching the pattern from mig 082, 099, 100, 103, 106, 110, 127, 129.
Creates the three new tables that split today's paliad.deadline_rules
into its three latent concepts, plus two nullable link columns on
paliad.deadlines for B.2 dual-write.
ADDITIVE ONLY. paliad.deadline_rules is untouched. deadlines.rule_id
stays in place — it remains the authoritative deadline → rule link
until B.3 cutover flips reads and B.4 drops the legacy table.
* paliad.legal_sources — distinct citations (87 rows backfilled).
pretty_de/pretty_en deferred (Go
legalSourcePretty still computes them
on read; future slice backfills).
* paliad.procedural_events — 153 rows from distinct submission_codes
+ 78 synthetic-code rows for the
NULL-submission_code branch (m's pick
via paliadin 2026-05-26: mint
'null.<8hex>' codes so every rule row
has a procedural event, preserving the
NOT NULL FK on sequencing_rules).
* paliad.sequencing_rules — 1:1 with deadline_rules (231 rows). id
inherited from deadline_rules.id so any
existing deadlines.rule_id FK resolves
transitively to the new sequencing_rule
during the dual-write window.
* paliad.deadlines.procedural_event_id, sequencing_rule_id (nullable,
backfilled by JOIN on the inherited id).
Audit-first pattern (mirrors mig 135): PRE pass counts what we're about
to backfill + refuses to run if multi-row submission_codes have crept
back in (B.0 found zero; the assertion guards against a future
re-archival or rule-editor bug). POST pass asserts the four
invariants — procedural_events count, sequencing_rules 1:1,
legal_sources distinct-citation match, FK integrity — and RAISE
EXCEPTIONs on any mismatch so the transaction rolls back cleanly.
Design deviations from §4.1 (documented in the migration header):
- procedural_events.event_kind is NULLABLE. 89 live rules have NULL
event_type today (structural / parent-only rows in the proceeding
tree). Tightening to NOT NULL with 'other' fallback would lose
semantics; a later slice can do it after reclassification.
- legal_sources.pretty_de / pretty_en are NULLABLE. Materialising them
requires the Go-side legalSourcePretty(); deferred to a Go-driven
slice. Read path keeps computing them from the citation in the
meantime.
- submission_drafts is NOT modified (instruction scope is explicit:
tables + deadlines columns only).
Down migration: drops the two deadlines columns first, then
sequencing_rules → procedural_events → legal_sources in FK-safe
order. No data loss possible (deadline_rules is the source of truth
through B.3).
Test: internal/db/migration_136_test.go restates the four
invariants in Go so they survive PL/pgSQL refactors. Skipped without
TEST_DATABASE_URL.
Verified on live (read-only): 153 distinct codes + 78 distinct
synthetic-code candidates = 231 = deadline_rules row count. 87
distinct legal_sources. Zero 8-hex synthetic-code collisions in the
live UUIDs.
Hard-stop: B.2 dual-write requires explicit m greenlight before
RuleEditorService starts writing to the new tables. B.4 destructive
drop additionally requires m's downtime window + a
paliad.deadline_rules_pre_<N> snapshot in the same migration.
Lays the foundation for youpc.org's cross-repo integration: an
in-package UPC subset of paliad's deadline corpus, embedded as JSON,
that any consumer can use to run the litigationplanner engine without
DB access.
Generator (cmd/gen-upc-snapshot):
- Reads paliad's live DB (DATABASE_URL), applies pending migrations
to match schema HEAD, SELECTs the UPC subset
(proceeding_types WHERE jurisdiction='UPC' AND is_active=true,
deadline_rules WHERE lifecycle_state='published' AND is_active=true
on those proceedings, referenced trigger_events, DE+UPC holidays,
UPC courts).
- Writes pretty-printed JSON to
pkg/litigationplanner/embedded/upc/{proceeding_types, rules,
trigger_events, holidays, courts, meta}.json.
- Idempotent — same DB state → same output (modulo
meta.generated_at + auto-versioned suffix).
- Date-stamped versioning (YYYY-MM-DD-N) with same-day suffix bump.
- Operator runbook in cmd/gen-upc-snapshot/README.md.
Embedded subpackage (pkg/litigationplanner/embedded/upc/):
- embed.go — //go:embed *.json + LoadMeta()
- snapshot.go — SnapshotCatalog (full lp.Catalog impl: LoadProceeding
/ LoadProceedingByID / LoadRuleByID / LoadRuleByCode /
LoadRulesByTriggerEvent / LoadTriggerEventsByIDs / LookupEvents);
O(1) map lookups; LookupEvents linear over the < 100-row UPC corpus.
- holidays.go — SnapshotHolidayCalendar implementing lp.HolidayCalendar
(IsNonWorkingDay / Adjust* with structured AdjustmentReason).
- courts.go — SnapshotCourtRegistry implementing lp.CourtRegistry.
- Compile-time assertions (_ lp.X = (*Snapshot*)(nil)) catch
interface drift.
Wire-up for consumers:
cat, _ := upc.NewCatalog()
hc, _ := upc.NewHolidayCalendar()
cr, _ := upc.NewCourtRegistry()
timeline, _ := lp.Calculate(ctx, "upc.inf.cfi", "2026-05-26",
lp.CalcOptions{}, cat, hc, cr)
Tests (snapshot_test.go, all DB-free):
- meta parses cleanly, non-zero counts
- LoadProceeding(upc.inf.cfi) returns expected proc + rules
- LoadProceeding(unknown) returns ErrUnknownProceedingType
- LookupEvents(Jurisdiction:UPC, all-following) covers corpus
- LookupEvents(party=defendant, next) scopes anchors correctly
- engine end-to-end via lp.Calculate against the embedded snapshot
- holiday calendar (weekends, DE closures, UPC vacation block)
- court registry (empty courtID fallback, known + unknown court)
Placeholder data shipped (2 proceedings, 2 rules, 5 holidays, 2
courts) so tests run without a live DB. Operator regenerates against
prod via `make snapshot-upc` once migrations 134 (B1) and 135 (B3)
have landed on prod — see cmd/gen-upc-snapshot/README.md for the
runbook. The placeholder's meta.version is suffixed `-placeholder`
to make the regeneration delta obvious.
Makefile target:
make snapshot-upc — wraps the generator + reruns the snapshot tests
Design (§19 of docs/design-litigation-planner-2026-05-26.md):
- Embedding format: go:embed JSON (diff-friendly, no compile coupling)
- Generator entry: cmd/gen-upc-snapshot/main.go (idiomatic Go cmd path)
- Versioning: meta.json carries semver + generated_at + paliad_commit
- Regeneration: manual via Make target or `go generate`; no CI cron in v1
- Out of scope: snapshot signing, DE/EPA/DPMA snapshots, snapshot
diff tooling
Acceptance:
- go build clean, go test all green (incl. 6 new tests in
pkg/litigationplanner/embedded/upc, all DB-free)
- SnapshotCatalog passes the compile-time lp.Catalog assertion
- Generator binary builds + runs (Idempotence verified by re-running
against the same source data)
mig 134 was inserting code='upc.apl' (2 segments) into paliad.proceeding_types,
which carries paliad_proceeding_code_shape CHECK requiring 3 dot-segments OR
'^_archived_'. Every container restart hit the constraint, rolled the migration
TXN back, and crash-looped paliad.de.
Rename the unified Berufung code to 'upc.apl.unified' (3 segments, satisfies the
constraint, preserves design intent). The pre-existing constraint is a useful
jurisdiction.category.specific invariant — keep it, fix the new row.
Touched only string literals:
- mig 134 up.sql + down.sql (insert, lookups, post-checks)
- frontend/src/verfahrensablauf.tsx (UPC_TYPES code + i18nKey)
- frontend/src/client/verfahrensablauf.ts (APPELLANT_AXIS + APPEAL_TARGET sets)
- frontend/src/client/i18n.ts (DE + EN translation rows)
- frontend/src/i18n-keys.ts (auto-regen via bun build)
- internal/services/lookup_events_test.go (anchor-row assertion)
Verified: `grep -rn "'upc\.apl'\|\"upc\.apl\""` returns zero hits.
go build, bun run build, go test ./... all green.
Tightens paliad.deadline_rules.primary_party from free-text to a CHECK
constraint over the canonical four-value vocab (claimant / defendant /
court / both). NULL stays valid for the 78 cross-cutting orphan
concept seeds (Wiedereinsetzung, Versäumnisurteil-Einspruch,
Schriftsatznachreichung, Weiterbehandlung) — they have no
proceeding_type_id binding so they're outside the calculator's path;
loosening the CHECK to "IS NULL OR IN (…)" keeps them valid without
backfill gymnastics.
Migration 135 (audit-first):
- DO block RAISEs NOTICE for every non-conforming row + RAISEs
EXCEPTION if any dirty rows exist (manual cleanup required).
Live audit (Supabase, 2026-05-26 §18.0) confirmed zero dirty rows
on the current corpus; the audit pass stays in the migration as
safety against future drift.
- ALTER TABLE … ADD CONSTRAINT deadline_rules_primary_party_chk
CHECK (primary_party IS NULL OR primary_party IN
('claimant', 'defendant', 'court', 'both'))
- Post-migration distribution NOTICE so the operator sees the
final per-value count.
- Down = DROP CONSTRAINT. No data revert needed.
Package additions (pkg/litigationplanner):
- PrimaryParty* constants (PrimaryPartyClaimant / Defendant / Court
/ Both) + PrimaryParties[] ordered list + IsValidPrimaryParty(s)
predicate. Empty string is "no value supplied" = valid (NULL maps
to empty on the wire); non-empty must match one of the four
canonical values.
- Sibling unit tests (primary_party_test.go) pin the four-value
vocab + the chip order + IsValidAppealTarget's matching shape.
Rule-editor validation hook (rule_editor_service.go):
- Create() validates input.PrimaryParty before INSERT.
- UpdateDraft() validates patch.PrimaryParty before UPDATE.
- Both surface a user-friendly 400 with the canonical vocab listed
instead of leaking the raw PG CHECK constraint-violation message.
- Uses errors.Is(err, ErrInvalidInput) so handler 400 routing
continues to work.
services/fristenrechner.go cleanup:
- The B2-inlined isValidPartyForLookup helper is replaced with the
canonical lp.IsValidPrimaryParty. No behaviour change.
No frontend changes — the rule-editor's primary_party UI already
constrains to the four values via a select; the validation hook is
defense-in-depth.
Audit:
- go build + go test (incl. new lp unit tests) all green
- Pre-migration audit confirmed: 26 claimant + 26 defendant + 38
court + 63 both + 78 NULL = 231 total, all in canonical vocab
- event_categories.party (text[] array, narrower semantic) is
NOT touched in this migration per the design doc's
"out of scope, separate follow-up" decision
New Catalog.LookupEvents(ctx, axes, depth) method exposes a unified
graph query over paliad.deadline_rules + paliad.proceeding_types + the
deadline_concept_event_types junction. Used by the Determinator
cascade, the scenarios surface (Slice D), and any future "show me
events matching X" query — centralises a fan-out that today is
duplicated across multiple client-side paths.
Package additions (pkg/litigationplanner):
- EventLookupAxes: optional Jurisdiction / *ProceedingTypeID / Party
/ *EventCategoryID / AppealTarget. All fields optional; the empty
value (or nil pointer) is "no filter on this axis". Multiple
non-zero axes apply as AND.
- EventLookupDepth: "next" (1 hop downstream) or "all-following"
(full chain).
- EventMatch: Rule + ProceedingType + Priority + DepthFromAnchor +
*ParentRuleID (populated only when the parent itself is in the
returned set, so the frontend can render a tree).
- Catalog interface gains LookupEvents.
paliad-side implementation (internal/services/fristenrechner.go):
- SQL pass with progressively-built WHERE clauses (one $N
placeholder per non-zero axis). EventCategoryID uses an EXISTS
subquery against paliad.event_category_concepts joined via
concept_id.
- Post-fetch parent_id graph walk in Go for depth control. Loads
the per-proceeding rule corpus via DeadlineRuleService.List so
children whose parent_id is in the anchor set can be added even
when those children don't match the axes themselves. AllFollowing
iterates to fixpoint; Next stops after one pass.
- DepthFromAnchor computed by walking each result row up the
parent_id chain until it hits an anchor (iteration-bounded to
prevent infinite loops on hypothetical cycles).
- Unknown axis values (jurisdiction="XX", party="foo",
appealTarget="invalid") silently fall through as "no filter on
this axis" — a stale frontend chip should not drop the entire
result set.
- "published + active" gate (lifecycle_state='published' AND
is_active=true) matches LoadProceeding's WHERE clause.
- Results ordered by (proceeding_type_id, sequence_order) so the
frontend can render without re-sorting.
Tests (internal/services/lookup_events_test.go):
- Live-DB driven (skipped without TEST_DATABASE_URL, matches the
existing TestCalculateRule pattern).
- Cases: UPC-jurisdiction returns the UPC corpus only;
party=defendant scopes anchor matches to defendant rules;
unknown jurisdiction falls through; appeal_target=endentscheidung
returns the merits rules from B1 mig 134;
appeal_target=schadensbemessung returns empty (no rules seeded).
No schema delta. No frontend wiring (the new HTTP endpoint at
GET /api/tools/lookup-events can land in a follow-up slice — the
package + paliad-side impl are the deliverable here).
Collapses the 3 UPC appeal proceeding_types (upc.apl.merits 7 rules,
upc.apl.cost 2, upc.apl.order 7 = 16 total across 3 codes) into ONE
unified upc.apl proceeding type + a per-rule applies_to_target[]
discriminator. The verfahrensablauf picker now shows one "Berufung"
tile; after picking it, the user selects which decision the appeal is
directed AT via a 5-chip group (Endentscheidung / Kostenentscheidung /
Anordnung / Schadensbemessung / Bucheinsicht) and the engine filters
rules whose applies_to_target contains the picked slug.
m's 2026-05-26 decision: Schadensbemessung-as-appeal is a NEW first-
class target with its OWN rule set (no shared inheritance from
merits). The 5 enum values are all defined + addressable; for now
schadensbemessung and bucheinsicht return empty timelines until rules
are seeded in a follow-up slice (likely via /admin/rules or pairing
with t-paliad-193 orphan-concept-seed).
Migration 134 (additive only):
- ADD proceeding_types.appeal_target text (CHECK on 5 slugs OR NULL)
- ADD deadline_rules.applies_to_target text[] (CHECK each element
in the 5 slugs)
- INSERT the unified upc.apl row (inherits sort/color from
upc.apl.merits)
- Audit-first RAISE NOTICE pass listing every row about to be
touched + a post-migration sanity check
- Reassign rule rows: merits → applies_to_target={endentscheidung},
cost → {kostenentscheidung}, order → {anordnung}
- Archive (is_active=false, NOT DELETE) the 3 old proceeding_types
so historical FKs stay intact
- Down migration restores is_active=true on the 3 old types, points
rules back by their applies_to_target stamp, drops the unified
row, drops both columns. Safe.
Package additions (pkg/litigationplanner):
- AppealTarget* constants + AppealTargets[] ordered list +
IsValidAppealTarget(s) predicate (silent no-op on unknown slugs
so a stale frontend chip doesn't break the render)
- ProceedingType.AppealTarget *string field (top-level marker;
NULL on non-appeal proceedings)
- Rule.AppliesToTarget pq.StringArray field (per-row applies-to set)
- CalcOptions.AppealTarget string (engine filter — when set,
keeps only rules whose AppliesToTarget contains the slug)
Engine filter runs after ApplyRuleOverrides but before the rule walk
so the existing condition_expr / spawn / appellant-context machinery
operates on the filtered subset transparently.
paliad-side wiring:
- deadline_rule_service.go: ruleColumns + proceedingTypeColumns
extended to scan the new columns
- handlers/fristenrechner.go: AppealTarget JSON field on the
request payload, threaded into CalcOptions
Frontend (verfahrensablauf surface only):
- Single "Berufung" tile replaces the 3 separate Berufung tiles
- New 5-chip appeal-target row, shown only when upc.apl is picked
- URL state ?target=<slug>; default endentscheidung when none set
- APPELLANT_AXIS_PROCEEDINGS updated: upc.apl.* (3 entries) →
upc.apl (1 entry)
- i18n keys (DE + EN) for the new tile + the 5 chip labels +
the "Worauf richtet sich die Berufung?" / "Appeal against:" prompt
- calculateDeadlines threads appealTarget through to the API
Acceptance:
- go build clean, go test all green (existing test suite — no new
tests on the engine filter as a follow-up; the migration's
sanity-check DO block guards the rule-reassignment count)
- Live audit before drafting confirmed: 3 active UPC appeal
proceeding_types, 16 rules total, primary_party already conforms
to 4-value vocab on all proceeding-bound rules
Slice B.0 — read-only re-validation of cronus's procedural-events design
against the live youpc Supabase paliad schema, 24 h after the design was
authored.
* Adds docs/design-procedural-events-b0-findings-2026-05-26.md with the
drift table, per-check confirmations, and a tightened B.1 brief.
* Annotates the cronus design doc's status header to point at the B.0
findings file so future readers see both together.
* Fixes the self-contradictory sentence in §1 that referenced
`deadline_rule_id` on both sides of a "not" — the live column is
`paliad.deadlines.rule_id`, renamed directly to
`paliad.deadlines.procedural_event_id` under Slice B (no intermediate
step). Matching fix patched into the m/paliad#93 issue body via
Gitea API (curl --netrc-file ~/.netrc-mai PATCH).
Key drift surfaced (vs design 2026-05-25):
- deadline_rules rows 254 → 231
- distinct submission_codes 158 → 153 (10 _archived_litigation.* codes
gone — Q5 multi-row collapse premise is now MOOT)
- distinct legal_sources 70 → 87 (+17)
- concept-linked rules 125 → 129
- paliad.deadlines rows 1 → 5
- submission_drafts rows 4 → 7
- live mig head 123 → 133; next available = 134 (not 124)
No migration SQL written. No writes to paliad.deadline_rules. Researcher
stays parked pending m's B.1 greenlight.
Note: this commit also cherry-picks the original inventor design doc
(5bb6df6) onto the B.0 branch, because the design was never merged to
main and the doc bug fix needed somewhere to land.
Atomic extraction of the deadline-rule compute engine + types from
internal/services into a new pkg/litigationplanner package that paliad
+ youpc.org can both import. No behaviour change — every existing test
passes against the post-move shape.
Package contents (~1850 LoC):
- doc.go package docstring + reuse manifesto
- types.go Rule, ProceedingType, NullableJSON, AdjustmentReason,
HolidayDTO, CalcOptions, CalcRuleParams, Timeline,
TimelineEntry, RuleCalculation*, FristenrechnerType,
ProjectHint, sentinel errors
- catalog.go Catalog interface (proceeding + rule lookups)
- holidays.go HolidayCalendar interface
- courts.go CourtRegistry interface + DefaultsForJurisdiction +
country/regime constants
- expr.go EvalConditionExpr + HasConditionExpr +
ExtractFlagsFromExpr (jsonb gate evaluator)
- durations.go ApplyDuration + AddWorkingDays (pure compute)
- subtrack.go SubTrackRouting + LookupSubTrackRouting registry
- legal_source.go FormatLegalSourceDisplay + BuildLegalSourceURL
- proceeding_mapping.go MapLitigationToFristenrechner + code constants
(CodeUPCInfringement, CodeDEInfringementLG, ...)
- engine.go Calculate + CalculateRule + the trigger-event
branch + applyRuleOverrides (the big move)
paliad side (~1900 LoC net deletion):
- internal/services/fristenrechner.go shrinks from 1505 → ~290 lines
(thin paliad Catalog adapter + type aliases for back-compat).
- internal/models/models.go: DeadlineRule, ProceedingType, NullableJSON
become type aliases to litigationplanner.* — every sqlx scan and
every projection_service caller compiles unchanged.
- internal/services/holidays.go: AdjustmentReason + HolidayDTO become
aliases to lp.* (canonical definitions now in the package).
- internal/services/proceeding_mapping.go: rewritten as thin re-exports
of lp constants + helpers.
- internal/services/deadline_search_service.go: FormatLegalSourceDisplay
+ BuildLegalSourceURL replaced with delegating wrappers to lp.
Catalog interface satisfaction:
- DeadlineRuleService → paliadCatalog adapter (wraps the existing
service, replicates the original SELECT shapes).
- HolidayService → satisfies lp.HolidayCalendar directly (compile-
time assertion at end of fristenrechner.go).
- CourtService → satisfies lp.CourtRegistry directly.
Wire shape is byte-identical. JSON tags on Rule / ProceedingType /
Timeline / TimelineEntry / RuleCalculation match the historical
UIResponse / UIDeadline shape; the frontend reads the same bytes.
Slice B (Catalog interface + paliad loader cleanup) is folded into
this commit since Slice A already needs the interfaces to call
Calculate across the boundary. Slice C (embedded UPC snapshot +
generator) is the next coder shift; the Berufung unification m
called out lands in Slice B/C per head's brief.
Refs: docs/design-litigation-planner-2026-05-26.md
m's 2026-05-26 decisions:
- Q1 composition: primary+spawned (v1) with multi-proceeding peer compose as v2 goal — jsonb spec architected for N entries from day 1
- Q2 scope: per-project + abstract (project_id NULL = abstract saved templates)
- Q3 dates: per-anchor overrides over one base date (matches today's compute)
- Q4 storage: new paliad.scenarios table with jsonb spec (NOT project_event_choices column extension)
- "users should not add their own rules" — original Slice E (user-authored rules) DROPPED, replaced with abstract scenarios surface on /tools/verfahrensablauf
§5 rewritten with new schema (paliad.scenarios + active_scenario_id FK), jsonb spec shape (proceedings[] array, version-tagged), validate-on-load discipline, multi-peer v2 path. §6 struck-through with original body preserved as historical context. §10 slice plan revised: Slice E = abstract scenarios surface, not user-authored rules. §0.5 added with decision matrix; §13 marked resolved.
Package shape (§2 §3) unchanged — library was decoupled from persistence/UI choices by design.
Inventor design for m/paliad#124. Atomic extract of FristenrechnerService /
DeadlineCalculator / proceeding_mapping / SubTrackRoutings / legal-source
helpers into pkg/litigationplanner with Catalog / HolidayCalendar /
CourtRegistry interfaces. youpc.org reuse via embedded UPC snapshot
(catalog.json + holidays.json + courts.json) shipped inside the package.
6 slices: A extract, B catalog interface, C embedded snapshot + generator,
D scenarios persistence (project_event_choices.scenario_name), E
user-authored rules (deadline_rules.project_id), F youpc-side PR.
Q1 + Q2 (material) escalated to head per inventor protocol — NOT
AskUserQuestion. Q3-Q5 locked. Decision picks (R) noted; doc holds together
under any answer to the open Qs because pkg shape is decoupled from
persistence choices.
m/paliad#127 — m's correction to #88. The user-perspective labels
"Unsere Seite" / "Gegnerseite" only make sense once the user has picked
a side; while side === null (Nicht festgelegt, the default after #120)
the column headers fall back to the semantic-neutral pair
"Proaktiv" / "Reaktiv". Picking a side re-enables the #88 labels.
renderColumnsBody now branches the leftLabel / rightLabel pair on the
incoming side. Bucketing primitive untouched: column placement is
unchanged, only the column-header text differs.
New i18n keys deadlines.col.proactive / deadlines.col.reactive (DE +
EN). The label fallback is documented inline in
verfahrensablauf-core.ts so a future reader sees why the columns have
two header modes.
Tests: four renderColumnsBody assertions covering side=null (explicit
+ default), side=claimant, side=defendant. Existing bucketing tests
unchanged.
Workflow shifted to hand-written numbered migrations; the audit-row SQL
export tool no longer has any consumers. Pure deletion — /admin/rules
and /admin/rules/{id}/edit stay; only the export-to-SQL flow goes.
Deleted:
- frontend/src/admin-rules-export.tsx
- frontend/src/client/admin-rules-export.ts
Removed:
- routes GET /admin/rules/export and GET /admin/api/rules/export-migrations
- handleAdminExportRuleMigrations + handleAdminRulesExportPage
- RuleEditorService.ExportMigrationsSince + ExportResult + sqlEscape helper
- build.ts entries (import, client bundle, dist HTML write)
- Sidebar "Regel-Migrations" nav item + "Migrations exportieren" button on /admin/rules
- all admin.rules.export.* + nav.admin.rules_export + admin.rules.list.export i18n keys (DE+EN)
- .admin-rules-export-* CSS rules (dead after page deletion)
Doc references in design-fristen-phase2-2026-05-15.md and
design-paliad-data-export-2026-05-19.md updated to mark the endpoint as
removed (acceptance #2 requires grep to return zero hits).
Optional events anchored on the same trigger (e.g. the four
post-Entscheidung rules in upc.inf.cfi) used to render in catalog
sequence_order, so a 2-month rule (R.118.4 Folgeentscheidungen)
would precede a 1-month rule (R.151 Kostenentscheidung) chained
off the same decision. Now the calculator does a post-evaluation
permutation pass that sorts consecutive same-parent rows by
duration ascending — days < weeks < months < years, ties broken
by duration_value then submission_code.
Different trigger groups keep their proceeding-sequence position
— the walk only ever permutes rows that already share a parent.
Root rules (no parent) are never sorted against each other.
Court-set / conditional rows whose date isn't in the duration
ladder sort LAST within their group.
Verified order against m's report: R.151 cost_app + R.353
rectification (1-month tier) now render before R.220.1
appeal_spawn + R.118.4 cons_orders (2-month tier).
Issue: m/paliad#128
t-paliad-294 / m/paliad#126. knuth's #121 conditional-rendering
defaulted the "abhängig von <parent>" chip to the rule's parent_id
display name. For R.262(2) Erwiderung auf Vertraulichkeitsantrag the
parent_id resolves to the SoC (Klageerhebung), but the rule's real
semantic anchor is the opposing party's confidentiality application
(paliad.trigger_events id=25). The chip read "abhängig von
Klageerhebung", which is wrong.
Fix: when a rule has a non-NULL trigger_event_id, the engine stamps
ParentRuleCode / ParentRuleName / ParentRuleNameEN from the
trigger_events catalog row instead of from the parent_id chain. The
parent_id stays as the calc-time arithmetic anchor — only the user-
facing dependency identity shifts.
Generalises across every rule with a real trigger_event_id (2 rows
in the live corpus today: confidentiality_response and
translations_lodge — both relabel correctly).
Touches both surfaces in one shot: verfahrensablauf-core's chip
("abhängig von …") and shape-timeline's "Folgt aus …" footer both
read from ParentRule*, so no frontend change needed.
Tests: extend TestUIDeadline_IsConditional_UncertainAnchors with a
DE+EN string-pinning case for R.262(2) plus a generalisation guard
for translations_lodge. Negative guard asserts the chip no longer
leaks "Klageerhebung" / "Statement of Claim".
m/paliad#125 — concern A (horizontal scroll) and concern B (compact
event-card UX).
Concern A: the inline "Wieder einblenden" chip from t-paliad-290 pushed
hidden cards past their column width on 375/414/768, causing horizontal
page scroll. Fix: drop the chip entirely; surface the un-hide as a
prominent "Wieder einblenden" entry inside the caret popover (matches
the m's "actions live in the caret menu" framing). The card title row
now also wraps + shrinks (flex-wrap + min-width:0 + overflow-wrap)
so no inline child can ever blow the row width.
Concern B (the bigger UX): cards now speak m's "cut the tree of
possibilities" vocabulary via iconified state markers in the title row:
- Optional event → ⊙ (timeline-state-icon--optional)
- Hidden by user → 👁⃠ (timeline-state-icon--hidden)
- Conditional anchor → already covered by the "abhängig von <parent>"
chip on the date column (t-paliad-289); no duplicate marker.
- CCR-included / appellant picks → already on the per-card chip.
The legacy `.optional-badge` text chip and `.event-card-choices-unhide`
inline chip are gone — both replaced by the icon language + popover
entry.
Renderer wires the unhide path with two contracts:
- data-is-hidden="1" on the caret button when isHidden=true, so the
popover knows to render the prominent unhide block on top.
- Defensive fallback: if a rule's choices_offered was edited away
after the user had already saved skip=true (so isHidden=true but
choicesOffered is empty), the renderer synthesizes {skip:[true,
false]} so the popover still has an un-hide path.
CSS:
- .timeline-item min-height 4rem → 2.75rem (less vertical air).
- .timeline-content padding-bottom 1rem → 0.6rem (tighter gutter).
- .timeline-item-header gains flex-wrap + min-width:0.
- .timeline-name gains min-width:0 + overflow-wrap:anywhere
(long German compounds wrap mid-word instead of overflowing).
- New: .timeline-state-icon[--optional|--hidden] icon-style markers.
- New: .event-card-choices-unhide-btn — prominent full-width lime
pill inside the popover, midnight-text in both themes (matches
the active-option pin from m/paliad#123).
i18n:
- state.optional.tooltip — "Optionales Ereignis" / "Optional event"
- state.hidden.tooltip — "Ausgeblendet — über Optionen-Menü wieder
einblenden" / "Hidden — restore via the options menu"
- choices.unhide.chip kept (now used as the popover button label).
Tests: 27 → 29 tests in verfahrensablauf-core.test.ts. Old isHidden
inline-chip cases replaced by state-icon + caret-data-is-hidden
contract cases. Added defensive-fallback case for the synthesized
skip offer. Added regression guard that the legacy
.event-card-choices-unhide class is no longer emitted. Added
optional-priority → ⊙ icon contract pair.
Hard rules respected:
- Title + date + Rule citation unchanged (m likes these).
- Click-to-edit on date span (.frist-date-edit) untouched.
- Conditional rendering (t-paliad-289 chip + dotted border) untouched.
- Per-card actions (skip, appellant pick, include-CCR, unhide) all
reachable via the caret popover.
go build ./... && go test ./internal/... && cd frontend && bun run
build && bun test — all green (181 tests).
Rules anchored on uncertain triggers (R.109 backward-anchor without
oral-hearing date; R.118(4) without validity decision; R.262(2)
without recorded Vertraulichkeitsantrag) previously rendered concrete
dates fabricated off the trigger date. Add IsConditional projection
flag so the SmartTimeline + Verfahrensablauf surfaces "abhängig von
<parent>" instead of a misleading date.
Backend (fristenrechner.go):
- Add IsConditional + ParentRuleCode/Name/NameEN to UIDeadline.
- Pre-pass populates courtSet from rule.is_court_set=true BEFORE the
main loop, so order-of-evaluation in sequence_order no longer matters
for the parent-court-set check. Fixes R.109(1) "Antrag auf
Simultanübersetzung" (sequence_order=45 < Mündliche Verhandlung's
sequence_order=50): the timing='before' backward arithmetic was
computing 1 month before the trigger date because the court-set
parent hadn't been classified yet.
- Set IsConditional=true on every IsCourtSetIndirect branch (catches
R.109 backward + R.118(4) cons_orders chain off the decision).
- Set IsConditional=true for priority='optional' + primary_party='both'
rules whose data-model parent is the trigger anchor (covers R.262(2)
confidentiality_response: the data anchors on SoC, but the real
trigger is the opposing party's confidentiality motion which may
never happen). Suppressed by IsOverridden so user anchors win.
Backend (projection_service.go):
- Add IsConditional to TimelineEvent + propagate from UIDeadline.
- New Status="conditional" for projected rows; clears Date, populates
DependsOnRuleCode/Name from UIDeadline.ParentRule* so the row
carries the "abhängig von <parent>" payload even when the parent
has no computed date for annotateDependsOn to discover.
Frontend (verfahrensablauf-core.ts + CSS + i18n):
- CalculatedDeadline gains isConditional + parentRule* fields.
- deadlineCardHtml renders "abhängig von <parent>" chip with
click-to-edit affordance in place of the date column when
isConditional=true. IsConditional wins over IsCourtSet for the
date column (they overlap; "abhängig von <parent>" names the
specific blocker).
- .timeline-item--conditional / .fr-col-item--conditional CSS:
dotted border + faded text so the conditional state reads at glance.
- Replaced escHtml's DOM-backed implementation with a pure-JS regex
escape so the module is testable in bun test without jsdom (the
old form forced fixtures to leave several fields empty just to
avoid the DOM dependency).
Tests:
- TestApplyLookaheadCap_ConditionalRowsPassThrough: pure-function lock
that conditional rows pass through applyLookaheadCap untouched
(don't count against ProjectedTotal/Shown, don't get capped).
- TestUIDeadline_IsConditional_UncertainAnchors (TEST_DATABASE_URL):
asserts R.109(1)/(4), R.118(4) chain, and R.262(2) all render
IsConditional=true with empty DueDate + populated ParentRule*; SoD
stays non-conditional; override on the oral hearing flips R.109(1)
back to concrete date.
- 4 new bun tests for the conditional rendering branches in
deadlineCardHtml.
UX path verified by tests + manual review of the live rule corpus:
opening a UPC inf project without oral-hearing date now surfaces
R.109(1) + R.109(4) as conditional; recording the Vertraulichkeitsantrag
(anchoring R.262(2) via the existing "Datum setzen" flow) flips it
back to a concrete date.
go build / go test / bun test / bun run build all clean.
Six surfaces paired a lime background with var(--color-text), which
flips to cream in dark mode and collapses contrast on the high-luminance
brand lime. Switch them to var(--color-accent-dark) — the design token
already defined to stay midnight in both themes as the WCAG-AA fg on
lime.
Affected:
- .event-card-choices-option--active (Berufung durch … popover —
m's primary report on m/paliad#123)
- .fristen-row.is-active .fristen-row-num
- .form-hint-badge
- .paliadin-widget-send-btn
- .smart-timeline-anchor-submit
- .admin-rules-chip.active
Lime hue and non-active states untouched.
Refs: m/paliad#123
Restructures the submission-draft sidebar per m's m/paliad#119 review.
Three changes on the variable form (Part B):
- VARIABLE_GROUPS collapses into four lawyer-facing sections: Mandant
& Verfahren (firm.* + project.* + procedural_event.*), Parteien
(manual {{parties.<role>.*}} overrides), Frist (the now-internal
deadline.* block, COLLAPSED by default since the skeletons no
longer render it), Sonstiges (today.* / user.* trim).
- Group sections are click-to-collapse via a sticky state map; the
Frist + Parteien-override sections open closed so the visible form
stays tight on first load.
- The legacy {{rule.*}} aliases drop off the sidebar — still resolved
by SubmissionVarsService for old templates, no longer surfaced as
override rows (they cluttered the form and the canonical
procedural_event.* names cover the same ground).
Multi-party + Add Party (Part C):
- The party picker now renders all three role buckets (claimants /
defendants / others) even when empty, so the lawyer can populate via
Add Party. The block is hidden only when no project is attached.
- Each side gets a "+ Partei hinzufügen (Klägerseite / Beklagtenseite
/ Weitere Parteien)" button that opens an inline panel with two
tabs:
- Manual entry — name, role (pre-filled from side), representative.
Submits to POST /api/projects/{id}/parties, creating a real
paliad.parties row that immediately surfaces in available_parties.
- Aus DB übernehmen — debounced (200ms) search against the new
GET /api/parties/search endpoint. Returns hits across every
visible project with project_title + reference for context.
Already-on-this-project rows are filtered out client-side. Picking
a hit clones name/role/representative into a fresh row on the
current project — the simplest semantics that survives the
paliad.parties.project_id NOT NULL contract while honouring m's
"no manual re-typing" requirement.
- Newly-added parties land in selected_parties immediately so the new
party is rendered in the next preview round-trip without an extra
click. Implicit-"all" default is preserved (empty selected_parties
still means "every party on the project, including this new one").
- Search-result repaints reach only into the <ul>, not the whole
picker — keeps focus + selection on the search input across
keystrokes.
CSS:
- Collapsible-section caret rotation, busy/disabled form states, tab
highlights, DB-picker result rows with project chip + hover, all
inherit the existing lime-tint accent so the new affordances look
native to the editor.
TSX:
- Comment update on the parties block; no structural change. The
bilingual hint copy in i18n.ts now nudges towards Add Party.
Adds PartyService.Search returning paliad.parties rows from every
project the caller can see, matched by case-insensitive substring on
name or representative. Wired via GET /api/parties/search?q=... — used
by the submission-draft Add-Party panel's "Aus DB übernehmen" tab.
Visibility flows through the same visibilityPredicatePositional helper
every project-scoped read uses; invisible projects' parties never
surface. Capped at 25 hits per call (no pagination — typical lookup is
"the party I'm thinking of by name", not a browse).
Result shape carries project_title + project_reference so the picker
can disambiguate identically-named parties across cases.
Per m's m/paliad#119 report: the {{deadline.*}} block was leaking
internal/admin context (Frist-Bezeichnung, Fälligkeit, "berechnet aus",
Quelle) into court-bound submissions. The dedicated Frist heading and
its 4 body lines are removed from both gen-skeleton-submission-template
(_skeleton.docx) and gen-hl-skeleton-template (_firm-skeleton.docx).
The {{deadline.due_date_long_en}} reference in the locale-aware
verification footer is also dropped. {{deadline.*}} placeholders stay
resolvable in SubmissionVarsService — a custom template can still pick
them up — but the default skeletons no longer render them in the body.
Regenerated .docx files uploaded to HL/mWorkRepo:
- 6 - material/Templates/Word/Paliad/HLC/_skeleton.docx → d0ecc0e
- 6 - material/Templates/Word/Paliad/HLC/_firm-skeleton.docx → 25954c9
m/paliad#122. atlas's #96 Slice A added per-card 'Überspringen' but no
un-skip path — hidden cards just disappeared from the timeline. This
adds the missing return path:
- CalcOptions.IncludeHidden (default false) tells the calculator to
re-surface skipRules entries as faded rows instead of dropping them.
When true, the rule renders with UIDeadline.IsHidden=true and the
descendant-suppression cascade is bypassed so children compute their
dates off the un-suppressed parent.
- UIResponse.HiddenCount always reflects the projection's hide count
(gate-passed rules whose submission_code is in skipRules) so the
"Ausgeblendete (N)" badge stays accurate regardless of toggle state.
- /tools/verfahrensablauf gets a "Ausgeblendete anzeigen" checkbox next
to the perspective + appellant selectors. URL-driven (?show_hidden=1)
so the state is shareable and survives reload. The row hides itself
on projections with zero hidden cards.
- Hidden cards render via .timeline-item--hidden / .fr-col-item--hidden
(opacity 0.55 + dotted border, mirroring the existing
--skipped fade) and carry an inline "Wieder einblenden" chip. Clicking
the chip removes the skip choice via the page's existing
attachEventCardChoices remove callback (URL state + recalc included)
and runs through a new delegated handler in event-card-choices.ts.
- 3 new i18n keys (DE+EN): choices.show_hidden.label,
choices.show_hidden.count, choices.unhide.chip.
The skip-choice storage shape (paliad.project_event_choices, atlas's
table) is unchanged — un-hide is just a delete of the skip row.
Tests: 3 new bun-test cases pin the chip contract (emits on isHidden=
true with submission_code, suppressed otherwise); go test ./internal/...
+ bun run build clean.
