m/projax
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues 5 Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

docs: Phase 5i Views — fold in m's decisions on the 9 open Qs

Browse Source 
m answered every open question directly via AskUserQuestion (greenlit
for inventor 2026-05-26 13:12). New §8.5 captures the picks + slice
implications. Inventor picks held on 6 of 9; m differed on Q5 (project
filter descendants) — wants an include-descendants toggle on the chip
rather than always-on, so Slice A grows an `IncludeDescendants` field
on TreeFilter + a toggle on the picker chip.

view_type enum locks at 5 (card/list/calendar/kanban/timeline). All
four out-of-scope items stay parked. No other slice changes.
This commit is contained in:
mAi
2026-05-26 13:15:53 +02:00
parent c6a350f6a0
commit 9138dfac59
1 changed files with 31 additions and 0 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

31
docs/plans/views-system.md
View File

@@ -391,6 +391,37 @@ Each slice is its own coder shift, its own branch, its own PR. No bundled big-ba
---
## §8.5 — m's decisions (2026-05-26)
All open questions answered by m directly via AskUserQuestion (m greenlit chip-picker for inventor 2026-05-26 13:12). Decisions captured below; §9 stays as the historical record of what was open.
| # | header | m picked | matches inventor pick? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Q1 | Timeline | Fifth view_type | yes |
| Q2 | View scope | Page-agnostic | yes |
| Q3 | enum size | 5 values (follows Q1) | yes |
| Q4 | Picker | Sidebar section under main nav | yes |
| Q5 | Proj scope | **Toggle on the chip** (include-descendants on/off) | **no** — inventor picked "always include descendants"; m wants explicit control |
| Q6 | Kanban grp | status (active/done/archived) | yes |
| Q7 | Save UI | HTMX modal | yes |
| Q8 | rename safety | (already resolved in §4: id authoritative, path display-only) | n/a |
| Q9 | Pull back into scope | none — all four stay parked | yes |
### Implications for the slicing
- **Q5 changes Slice A**: project filter chip needs an `include-descendants` boolean toggle next to the picker. Default state and TreeFilter field: `IncludeDescendants bool` (default `true` to match the most common case; toggle flips to `false` for single-item scope). URL param: `?project_descendants=0` when off (default-elided, so URLs stay short in the common case). Cache key implication: covered automatically by `QueryString()` once the field is in the emit set.
- **Q1 + Q3 lock the view_type enum at 5**: `card | list | calendar | kanban | timeline`. Migration `0016_views.sql` CHECK constraint uses all five.
- **Q9 confirms all four parked**: drag-to-change-group on kanban, multi-user/sharing, per-view notifications, cross-view diffs all stay out of Phase 5i. Slice C stays read-only as designed.
- **Q2 + Q4 + Q7 all match inventor picks**: design ships as drafted on those fronts.
### Concrete edits to the slicing in §7
- **Slice A** adds: `IncludeDescendants` field on TreeFilter, default true; toggle chip rendered next to the project picker on every Views-supporting page; `Matches` falls back to "primary path equality only" when off; round-trip test for the toggle.
- **Slice D** schema: `view_type` CHECK now includes `timeline`. No other change.
- All other slices unchanged.
---
## §9 — Open questions for head delegation
These are forks where data + code alone can't resolve the design. Single delegation to head with these batched; head surfaces to m; head relays answers.