Merge: t-paliad-285+286 — UPC Damages + PM appeal route deadlines (mig 133) (m/paliad#117, m/paliad#118)
This commit is contained in:
@@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
|
||||
-- Reverses mig 133. Removes the 5 new rules:
|
||||
-- * upc.dmgs.cfi.interim
|
||||
-- * upc.dmgs.cfi.oral
|
||||
-- * upc.dmgs.cfi.decision
|
||||
-- * upc.dmgs.cfi.appeal_spawn
|
||||
-- * upc.pi.cfi.appeal_spawn
|
||||
--
|
||||
-- The audit_reason is required by the mig 079 trigger for DELETE;
|
||||
-- set_config at top supplies it.
|
||||
--
|
||||
-- Idempotent — if a rule is already missing the DELETE matches zero
|
||||
-- rows and the audit log records nothing extra.
|
||||
|
||||
SELECT set_config(
|
||||
'paliad.audit_reason',
|
||||
'mig 133 (down): revert UPC Damages tree-end rows and UPC PI appeal-spawn (t-paliad-285 / m/paliad#117 + t-paliad-286 / m/paliad#118)',
|
||||
true);
|
||||
|
||||
-- Delete the spawn rows first so the parent_id reference goes away
|
||||
-- before the parent decision row is removed.
|
||||
DELETE FROM paliad.deadline_rules
|
||||
WHERE submission_code IN (
|
||||
'upc.dmgs.cfi.appeal_spawn',
|
||||
'upc.pi.cfi.appeal_spawn')
|
||||
AND lifecycle_state = 'published';
|
||||
|
||||
DELETE FROM paliad.deadline_rules
|
||||
WHERE submission_code IN (
|
||||
'upc.dmgs.cfi.interim',
|
||||
'upc.dmgs.cfi.oral',
|
||||
'upc.dmgs.cfi.decision')
|
||||
AND proceeding_type_id = 17
|
||||
AND lifecycle_state = 'published';
|
||||
405
internal/db/migrations/133_upc_dmgs_pi_court_followup.up.sql
Normal file
405
internal/db/migrations/133_upc_dmgs_pi_court_followup.up.sql
Normal file
@@ -0,0 +1,405 @@
|
||||
-- t-paliad-285 (m/paliad#117) + t-paliad-286 (m/paliad#118) —
|
||||
-- post-submission court followup for UPC Damages and appeal route
|
||||
-- for UPC Provisional Measures.
|
||||
--
|
||||
-- m's 2026-05-25 report: the upc.dmgs.cfi proceeding stops at the
|
||||
-- last party submission (rejoin) — no interim conference, no oral
|
||||
-- hearing, no decision row, no appeal-spawn. The upc.pi.cfi
|
||||
-- proceeding has its decision row (`pi.order`) but no spawn into
|
||||
-- the appeal tree. Both gaps prevent the Verfahrensablauf timeline
|
||||
-- from rendering the court phase plus any downstream appeal sub-
|
||||
-- tree that atlas's #96 spawn-rendering mechanism is otherwise
|
||||
-- ready to surface.
|
||||
--
|
||||
-- Two sections in one migration (slot 133 — knuth on 132, paliadin
|
||||
-- coordinated):
|
||||
--
|
||||
-- A. UPC Damages tree-end rows (#117)
|
||||
-- A1 upc.dmgs.cfi.interim UPC RoP R.105 court-set hearing
|
||||
-- A2 upc.dmgs.cfi.oral UPC RoP R.118 / R.250 court-set hearing
|
||||
-- A3 upc.dmgs.cfi.decision UPC RoP R.118 / R.144 court-set decision
|
||||
-- A4 upc.dmgs.cfi.appeal_spawn UPC RoP R.220.1(a) / R.224.1(a) 2mo, spawn → upc.apl.merits (id=11)
|
||||
--
|
||||
-- B. UPC Provisional Measures appeal route (#118)
|
||||
-- B1 upc.pi.cfi.appeal_spawn UPC RoP R.220.1(a) / R.224.1(a) 2mo, spawn → upc.apl.merits (id=11)
|
||||
--
|
||||
-- Source citations:
|
||||
-- * docs/research-deadlines-completeness-2026-05-25.md
|
||||
-- — §2.1 (upc.dmgs.cfi has only 4 rules: R.131.2 / R.137.2 / R.139)
|
||||
-- — §D Damages table (R.144 tree-end row missing — listed
|
||||
-- in Tier 4 as "cosmetic", upgraded to Tier-0 by m's
|
||||
-- report once the wider follow-up gap was understood)
|
||||
-- * docs/audit-upc-rop-deadlines-2026-05-08.md §D row R.144,
|
||||
-- §F R.220.1(a) / R.224.1(a) (verified verbatim in youpc DB
|
||||
-- under law_type=UPCRoP).
|
||||
-- * UPC Rules of Procedure (consolidated):
|
||||
-- R.105 — Interim conference (court fixes after written
|
||||
-- procedure closes; same structural shape as the inf
|
||||
-- interim conference, already modelled as `upc.inf.cfi.interim`).
|
||||
-- R.118 — Decision after oral hearing; general rule for
|
||||
-- deciding panels.
|
||||
-- R.250 — Determination of damages decision; damages-
|
||||
-- specific decision rule (chains R.144 indication →
|
||||
-- damages award).
|
||||
-- R.144 — Final decision on damages quantum (tree-end
|
||||
-- anchor for §A3).
|
||||
-- R.220.1(a) — Appeal lies from any final decision /
|
||||
-- decision disposing of the case at first instance.
|
||||
-- A PI order under R.211 disposes of the urgent question
|
||||
-- and is therefore appealable on the main 2-month track
|
||||
-- (not the 15-day order track of R.220.1(c), which covers
|
||||
-- case-management and procedural orders requiring leave).
|
||||
-- Curie's §F table confirms the main-track wiring for
|
||||
-- decisions on merits / disposing orders.
|
||||
-- R.224.1(a) — Statement of Appeal within 2 months of
|
||||
-- service of the final decision; the deadline-notes text
|
||||
-- mirrors mig 095's inf.appeal_spawn / rev.appeal_spawn.
|
||||
-- R.224.2(a) — Statement of grounds within 4 months
|
||||
-- (separate deadline in the spawned upc.apl.merits
|
||||
-- proceeding; already present as upc.apl.merits.grounds).
|
||||
--
|
||||
-- Shape decisions (mirroring mig 012 / mig 095 conventions):
|
||||
-- * Court-set rows (interim / oral / decision) carry
|
||||
-- primary_party='court', event_type='hearing'|'decision',
|
||||
-- duration_value=0, is_court_set=true, parent_id=NULL,
|
||||
-- concept_id reuses the shared concepts already wired for
|
||||
-- upc.inf.cfi (interim-conference / oral-hearing / decision).
|
||||
-- * Spawn rows carry primary_party='both', is_spawn=true,
|
||||
-- spawn_proceeding_type_id=11 (upc.apl.merits), spawn_label
|
||||
-- identical to the merits spawn already in production. The
|
||||
-- spawn row's parent_id is the spawning decision/order row
|
||||
-- (so the audit log carries the trigger link).
|
||||
-- * No condition_expr — m's F2.3 decision recorded in mig 095
|
||||
-- §3: "the appeal deadline should always be triggered by a
|
||||
-- decision … appeal is always a possibility." Visibility
|
||||
-- filtering on the frontend hides appeals on projects where
|
||||
-- no appeal is contemplated.
|
||||
-- * sequence_order numbering follows the inf convention
|
||||
-- (40=interim, 50=oral, 60=decision, 80=appeal_spawn) so the
|
||||
-- Verfahrensablauf timeline orders consistently across
|
||||
-- proceedings. For PI the existing pi.order sits at
|
||||
-- sequence_order=3; the appeal_spawn lands at 10 (clear of
|
||||
-- the writ phase, room for future court-phase rows).
|
||||
--
|
||||
-- Idempotency: every INSERT is gated by `WHERE NOT EXISTS (… same
|
||||
-- submission_code, proceeding_type_id, lifecycle_state)`. Re-apply
|
||||
-- against an already-migrated DB inserts zero rows and the audit
|
||||
-- log carries no duplicate entries.
|
||||
--
|
||||
-- audit_reason set_config required at the top — the mig 079 trigger
|
||||
-- on paliad.deadline_rules raises EXCEPTION 'audit reason required'
|
||||
-- on INSERT/UPDATE/DELETE without it.
|
||||
|
||||
SELECT set_config(
|
||||
'paliad.audit_reason',
|
||||
'mig 133: t-paliad-285 / m/paliad#117 + t-paliad-286 / m/paliad#118 — UPC Damages tree-end rows (interim conference R.105, oral hearing R.118/R.250, decision R.118/R.144, appeal-spawn R.220.1(a)) and UPC Provisional Measures appeal-spawn R.220.1(a); see docs/research-deadlines-completeness-2026-05-25.md §D and docs/audit-upc-rop-deadlines-2026-05-08.md §D/§F',
|
||||
true);
|
||||
|
||||
-- =============================================================================
|
||||
-- A. UPC Damages — court-phase tree end (m/paliad#117)
|
||||
-- =============================================================================
|
||||
|
||||
-- A1. upc.dmgs.cfi.interim — Interim conference (UPC RoP R.105).
|
||||
-- Court-set hearing fixed by the judge-rapporteur once the
|
||||
-- written procedure closes. Identical shape to
|
||||
-- upc.inf.cfi.interim; reuses the shared interim-conference
|
||||
-- concept node.
|
||||
INSERT INTO paliad.deadline_rules
|
||||
(proceeding_type_id, parent_id, submission_code, name, name_en,
|
||||
description, primary_party, event_type,
|
||||
duration_value, duration_unit, timing,
|
||||
rule_code, deadline_notes, deadline_notes_en, sequence_order,
|
||||
is_spawn, spawn_proceeding_type_id, spawn_label,
|
||||
is_active, legal_source, is_bilateral,
|
||||
condition_expr, priority, is_court_set, lifecycle_state,
|
||||
concept_id)
|
||||
SELECT
|
||||
17,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
'upc.dmgs.cfi.interim',
|
||||
'Zwischenverfahren',
|
||||
'Interim Conference',
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
'court',
|
||||
'hearing',
|
||||
0,
|
||||
'months',
|
||||
'after',
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
'Termin vom Gericht bestimmt',
|
||||
'Date set by the court',
|
||||
40,
|
||||
false,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
true,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
false,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
'optional',
|
||||
true,
|
||||
'published',
|
||||
'e5071152-d408-4455-b644-9e79d86fd538'
|
||||
WHERE NOT EXISTS (
|
||||
SELECT 1 FROM paliad.deadline_rules
|
||||
WHERE submission_code = 'upc.dmgs.cfi.interim'
|
||||
AND proceeding_type_id = 17
|
||||
AND lifecycle_state = 'published');
|
||||
|
||||
-- A2. upc.dmgs.cfi.oral — Oral hearing (UPC RoP R.118 / R.250).
|
||||
-- Court-set hearing after the interim conference / close of
|
||||
-- written procedure. Same shape as upc.inf.cfi.oral; reuses
|
||||
-- the shared oral-hearing concept node.
|
||||
INSERT INTO paliad.deadline_rules
|
||||
(proceeding_type_id, parent_id, submission_code, name, name_en,
|
||||
description, primary_party, event_type,
|
||||
duration_value, duration_unit, timing,
|
||||
rule_code, deadline_notes, deadline_notes_en, sequence_order,
|
||||
is_spawn, spawn_proceeding_type_id, spawn_label,
|
||||
is_active, legal_source, is_bilateral,
|
||||
condition_expr, priority, is_court_set, lifecycle_state,
|
||||
concept_id)
|
||||
SELECT
|
||||
17,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
'upc.dmgs.cfi.oral',
|
||||
'Mündliche Verhandlung',
|
||||
'Oral Hearing',
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
'court',
|
||||
'hearing',
|
||||
0,
|
||||
'months',
|
||||
'after',
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
50,
|
||||
false,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
true,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
false,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
'optional',
|
||||
true,
|
||||
'published',
|
||||
'd6e5b793-dcf1-4d83-81ff-34f42dbb3693'
|
||||
WHERE NOT EXISTS (
|
||||
SELECT 1 FROM paliad.deadline_rules
|
||||
WHERE submission_code = 'upc.dmgs.cfi.oral'
|
||||
AND proceeding_type_id = 17
|
||||
AND lifecycle_state = 'published');
|
||||
|
||||
-- A3. upc.dmgs.cfi.decision — Damages decision (UPC RoP R.118 /
|
||||
-- R.144 / R.250). Court-set decision delivered after oral
|
||||
-- hearing; closes the §3.1 audit gap (R.144 tree-end). Same
|
||||
-- shape as upc.inf.cfi.decision; reuses the shared decision
|
||||
-- concept node.
|
||||
INSERT INTO paliad.deadline_rules
|
||||
(proceeding_type_id, parent_id, submission_code, name, name_en,
|
||||
description, primary_party, event_type,
|
||||
duration_value, duration_unit, timing,
|
||||
rule_code, deadline_notes, deadline_notes_en, sequence_order,
|
||||
is_spawn, spawn_proceeding_type_id, spawn_label,
|
||||
is_active, legal_source, is_bilateral,
|
||||
condition_expr, priority, is_court_set, lifecycle_state,
|
||||
concept_id)
|
||||
SELECT
|
||||
17,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
'upc.dmgs.cfi.decision',
|
||||
'Entscheidung',
|
||||
'Decision',
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
'court',
|
||||
'decision',
|
||||
0,
|
||||
'months',
|
||||
'after',
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
60,
|
||||
false,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
true,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
false,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
'optional',
|
||||
true,
|
||||
'published',
|
||||
'472fc32d-cc4f-4aa4-8ace-e422031812de'
|
||||
WHERE NOT EXISTS (
|
||||
SELECT 1 FROM paliad.deadline_rules
|
||||
WHERE submission_code = 'upc.dmgs.cfi.decision'
|
||||
AND proceeding_type_id = 17
|
||||
AND lifecycle_state = 'published');
|
||||
|
||||
-- A4. upc.dmgs.cfi.appeal_spawn — Appeal against damages decision
|
||||
-- (UPC RoP R.220.1(a), 2-month main track; grounds R.224.2(a)
|
||||
-- run as a separate deadline in the spawned upc.apl.merits
|
||||
-- proceeding). Parent points at the freshly-inserted
|
||||
-- upc.dmgs.cfi.decision; the SELECT subquery resolves it
|
||||
-- after A3 lands. Same shape as the mig 095 inf.appeal_spawn.
|
||||
INSERT INTO paliad.deadline_rules
|
||||
(proceeding_type_id, parent_id, submission_code, name, name_en,
|
||||
description, primary_party, event_type,
|
||||
duration_value, duration_unit, timing,
|
||||
rule_code, deadline_notes, deadline_notes_en, sequence_order,
|
||||
is_spawn, spawn_proceeding_type_id, spawn_label,
|
||||
is_active, legal_source, is_bilateral,
|
||||
condition_expr, priority, is_court_set, lifecycle_state)
|
||||
SELECT
|
||||
17,
|
||||
(SELECT id FROM paliad.deadline_rules
|
||||
WHERE submission_code = 'upc.dmgs.cfi.decision'
|
||||
AND proceeding_type_id = 17
|
||||
AND lifecycle_state = 'published'
|
||||
AND is_active = true),
|
||||
'upc.dmgs.cfi.appeal_spawn',
|
||||
'Berufung gegen Schadensentscheidung',
|
||||
'Appeal against damages decision',
|
||||
'Berufung gegen die Entscheidung über die Schadensbemessung (R.118 / R.144). Statutarische Frist von 2 Monaten ab Zustellung der Entscheidung (R.224.1(a)); die Berufungsbegründung folgt mit 4 Monaten ab Zustellung (R.224.2(a), eigenständige Frist im Berufungsverfahren).',
|
||||
'both',
|
||||
'filing',
|
||||
2,
|
||||
'months',
|
||||
'after',
|
||||
'RoP.220.1.a',
|
||||
'Innerhalb von 2 Monaten ab Zustellung der Schadensentscheidung Berufungsschrift einreichen (R.224.1(a)). Die Berufungsbegründung (R.224.2(a), 4 Monate) läuft als separate Frist im Berufungsverfahren.',
|
||||
'Within 2 months of service of the damages decision lodge the Statement of appeal (R.224.1(a)). The Statement of grounds (R.224.2(a), 4 months) runs as an independent deadline in the appeal proceeding.',
|
||||
80,
|
||||
true,
|
||||
11,
|
||||
'Berufungsverfahren öffnen',
|
||||
true,
|
||||
'UPC.RoP.220.1',
|
||||
false,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
'optional',
|
||||
false,
|
||||
'published'
|
||||
WHERE NOT EXISTS (
|
||||
SELECT 1 FROM paliad.deadline_rules
|
||||
WHERE submission_code = 'upc.dmgs.cfi.appeal_spawn'
|
||||
AND proceeding_type_id = 17
|
||||
AND lifecycle_state = 'published');
|
||||
|
||||
-- =============================================================================
|
||||
-- B. UPC Provisional Measures — appeal route (m/paliad#118)
|
||||
-- =============================================================================
|
||||
|
||||
-- B1. upc.pi.cfi.appeal_spawn — Appeal against PI order (UPC RoP
|
||||
-- R.220.1(a), 2-month main track). PI orders under R.211
|
||||
-- dispose of the urgent question and are appealable on the
|
||||
-- main 2-month track (R.220.1(a)/R.224.1(a)); the 15-day
|
||||
-- order track of R.220.1(c) is for case-management /
|
||||
-- procedural orders requiring leave and does not apply to
|
||||
-- PI dispositions. Parent points at the existing
|
||||
-- upc.pi.cfi.order (sequence_order=3) so the spawn fires
|
||||
-- once the order is anchored on a project's timeline.
|
||||
INSERT INTO paliad.deadline_rules
|
||||
(proceeding_type_id, parent_id, submission_code, name, name_en,
|
||||
description, primary_party, event_type,
|
||||
duration_value, duration_unit, timing,
|
||||
rule_code, deadline_notes, deadline_notes_en, sequence_order,
|
||||
is_spawn, spawn_proceeding_type_id, spawn_label,
|
||||
is_active, legal_source, is_bilateral,
|
||||
condition_expr, priority, is_court_set, lifecycle_state)
|
||||
SELECT
|
||||
10,
|
||||
(SELECT id FROM paliad.deadline_rules
|
||||
WHERE submission_code = 'upc.pi.cfi.order'
|
||||
AND proceeding_type_id = 10
|
||||
AND lifecycle_state = 'published'
|
||||
AND is_active = true),
|
||||
'upc.pi.cfi.appeal_spawn',
|
||||
'Berufung gegen Anordnung',
|
||||
'Appeal against PI order',
|
||||
'Berufung gegen die einstweilige Anordnung nach R.211. Eine PI-Anordnung erledigt die einstweilige Streitfrage und wird wie eine Endentscheidung im Hauptverfahren behandelt: statutarische Frist von 2 Monaten ab Zustellung (R.224.1(a)); die Berufungsbegründung folgt mit 4 Monaten ab Zustellung (R.224.2(a), eigenständige Frist im Berufungsverfahren). Die 15-Tage-Spur nach R.220.1(c) / R.220.2 gilt für Verfahrensanordnungen mit Zulassung und ist hier nicht einschlägig.',
|
||||
'both',
|
||||
'filing',
|
||||
2,
|
||||
'months',
|
||||
'after',
|
||||
'RoP.220.1.a',
|
||||
'Innerhalb von 2 Monaten ab Zustellung der PI-Anordnung Berufungsschrift einreichen (R.224.1(a)). Die Berufungsbegründung (R.224.2(a), 4 Monate) läuft als separate Frist im Berufungsverfahren.',
|
||||
'Within 2 months of service of the PI order lodge the Statement of appeal (R.224.1(a)). The Statement of grounds (R.224.2(a), 4 months) runs as an independent deadline in the appeal proceeding.',
|
||||
10,
|
||||
true,
|
||||
11,
|
||||
'Berufungsverfahren öffnen',
|
||||
true,
|
||||
'UPC.RoP.220.1',
|
||||
false,
|
||||
NULL,
|
||||
'optional',
|
||||
false,
|
||||
'published'
|
||||
WHERE NOT EXISTS (
|
||||
SELECT 1 FROM paliad.deadline_rules
|
||||
WHERE submission_code = 'upc.pi.cfi.appeal_spawn'
|
||||
AND proceeding_type_id = 10
|
||||
AND lifecycle_state = 'published');
|
||||
|
||||
-- =============================================================================
|
||||
-- C. Post-insert verification — raise if any expected row is missing
|
||||
-- (matches the mig 095 / 127 convention; protects against a future
|
||||
-- re-shape of the table that silently drops one of the WHERE NOT
|
||||
-- EXISTS predicates).
|
||||
-- =============================================================================
|
||||
|
||||
DO $$
|
||||
DECLARE
|
||||
v_missing text;
|
||||
BEGIN
|
||||
SELECT string_agg(expected, ', ' ORDER BY expected)
|
||||
INTO v_missing
|
||||
FROM (VALUES
|
||||
('upc.dmgs.cfi.interim'),
|
||||
('upc.dmgs.cfi.oral'),
|
||||
('upc.dmgs.cfi.decision'),
|
||||
('upc.dmgs.cfi.appeal_spawn'),
|
||||
('upc.pi.cfi.appeal_spawn')
|
||||
) AS t(expected)
|
||||
WHERE NOT EXISTS (
|
||||
SELECT 1 FROM paliad.deadline_rules dr
|
||||
WHERE dr.submission_code = t.expected
|
||||
AND dr.lifecycle_state = 'published'
|
||||
AND dr.is_active = true);
|
||||
|
||||
IF v_missing IS NOT NULL THEN
|
||||
RAISE EXCEPTION
|
||||
'mig 133: expected published rules missing after insert: %', v_missing;
|
||||
END IF;
|
||||
|
||||
IF NOT EXISTS (
|
||||
SELECT 1 FROM paliad.deadline_rules dr
|
||||
WHERE dr.submission_code = 'upc.dmgs.cfi.appeal_spawn'
|
||||
AND dr.proceeding_type_id = 17
|
||||
AND dr.spawn_proceeding_type_id = 11
|
||||
AND dr.is_spawn = true
|
||||
AND dr.parent_id IS NOT NULL
|
||||
AND dr.lifecycle_state = 'published'
|
||||
) THEN
|
||||
RAISE EXCEPTION
|
||||
'mig 133: upc.dmgs.cfi.appeal_spawn shape check failed (expected is_spawn=true, spawn_proceeding_type_id=11, parent_id set)';
|
||||
END IF;
|
||||
|
||||
IF NOT EXISTS (
|
||||
SELECT 1 FROM paliad.deadline_rules dr
|
||||
WHERE dr.submission_code = 'upc.pi.cfi.appeal_spawn'
|
||||
AND dr.proceeding_type_id = 10
|
||||
AND dr.spawn_proceeding_type_id = 11
|
||||
AND dr.is_spawn = true
|
||||
AND dr.parent_id IS NOT NULL
|
||||
AND dr.lifecycle_state = 'published'
|
||||
) THEN
|
||||
RAISE EXCEPTION
|
||||
'mig 133: upc.pi.cfi.appeal_spawn shape check failed (expected is_spawn=true, spawn_proceeding_type_id=11, parent_id set)';
|
||||
END IF;
|
||||
END $$;
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user