Files
paliad/pkg/litigationplanner/before_court_set_anchor_test.go
mAi 3c840c0366
Some checks failed
Paliad CI gate / build (push) Has been cancelled
Paliad CI gate / test-go (push) Has been cancelled
Paliad CI gate / deploy (push) Has been cancelled
fix(litigationplanner): respect trigger_event_id + suppress optional from default (yoUPC#178 + #2568/#2570)
Two paired engine semantics fixes:

1. trigger_event_id is now the authoritative semantic anchor. When a
   rule carries trigger_event_id, the engine no longer falls back to
   the proceeding's trigger date — it resolves the anchor via
   CalcOptions.TriggerEventAnchors keyed by paliad.trigger_events.code.
   Missing anchor renders the rule as IsConditional (empty date) and
   propagates via courtSet so descendants also surface as conditional.
   Fixes the RoP.109.5 bug where the engine fabricated a date 2 weeks
   before the user's SoC instead of waiting for the oral_hearing date.

2. priority='optional' rules are suppressed from the default
   Calculate output. Callers (paliad /tools/procedures,
   youpc.org/deadlines) opt in via CalcOptions.IncludeOptional=true to
   restore the legacy "show optional applications" behaviour. The
   suppression cascades through skippedIDs so child rules drop too.

Wire shape additions:

  - CalcOptions.IncludeOptional bool
  - CalcOptions.TriggerEventAnchors map[string]string
  - Timeline.RulesAwaitingAnchor int (count of suppressed-by-missing-
    anchor rules, for caller telemetry / "N rules need an anchor" UX)

Existing before-court-set-anchor tests opt in to IncludeOptional=true
to preserve their non-optional-related test intent.

Refs: youpcorg/head delegations #2568 + #2570, m/paliad#153 (Litigation
Builder PRD path).
2026-05-28 00:04:30 +02:00

335 lines
12 KiB
Go

package litigationplanner
import (
"context"
"errors"
"testing"
"time"
"github.com/google/uuid"
)
// Regression test for t-paliad-304 / m/paliad#135.
//
// Reproduces the R.109.1 / R.109.4 anchor bug on upc.inf.cfi:
// - Trigger (Klageerhebung): parent_id=nil, duration=0, !IsCourtSet, sequence_order=0
// - Translation request: parent_id=oral, duration=1mo before, sequence_order=45
// - Interpreter cost: parent_id=oral, duration=2w before, sequence_order=46
// - Oral hearing: parent_id=nil, duration=0, IsCourtSet, sequence_order=50
//
// The "before" children are listed BEFORE the oral hearing in sequence
// order (because chronologically they happen before it). The engine walks
// rules in sequence_order, so when it processes the translation/
// interpreter rows, the oral hearing has not yet been processed →
// courtSet[oral.ID] is not yet set → parentIsCourtSet is false → the
// engine falls back to the trigger date as the base. Result: the timing=
// 'before' arithmetic produces 27.04.2026 (1mo before SoC) instead of
// the conditional-no-date treatment that a court-set parent should
// trigger.
//
// Expected post-fix: translation_request + interpreter_cost render as
// IsConditional (no concrete date) because their parent's date is
// court-set and the proceeding does not yet have an explicit override.
// stubCatalog implements lp.Catalog backed by an in-memory rule slice.
// Only LoadProceeding is needed for the engine path under test; the
// other interface methods return errors so an unintended call surfaces
// immediately.
type stubCatalog struct {
pt ProceedingType
rules []Rule
}
func (s *stubCatalog) LoadProceeding(_ context.Context, code string, _ ProjectHint) (*ProceedingType, []Rule, error) {
if code != s.pt.Code {
return nil, nil, ErrUnknownProceedingType
}
rules := make([]Rule, len(s.rules))
copy(rules, s.rules)
pt := s.pt
return &pt, rules, nil
}
func (s *stubCatalog) LoadProceedingByID(_ context.Context, _ int) (*ProceedingType, error) {
return nil, errors.New("stubCatalog.LoadProceedingByID: not implemented")
}
func (s *stubCatalog) LoadRuleByID(_ context.Context, _ string) (*Rule, error) {
return nil, errors.New("stubCatalog.LoadRuleByID: not implemented")
}
func (s *stubCatalog) LoadRuleByCode(_ context.Context, _, _ string) (*Rule, *ProceedingType, error) {
return nil, nil, errors.New("stubCatalog.LoadRuleByCode: not implemented")
}
func (s *stubCatalog) LoadRulesByTriggerEvent(_ context.Context, _ int64) ([]Rule, error) {
return nil, nil
}
func (s *stubCatalog) LoadTriggerEventsByIDs(_ context.Context, _ []int64) (map[int64]TriggerEvent, error) {
return map[int64]TriggerEvent{}, nil
}
func (s *stubCatalog) LookupEvents(_ context.Context, _ EventLookupAxes, _ EventLookupDepth) ([]EventMatch, error) {
return nil, nil
}
func (s *stubCatalog) LoadScenarios(_ context.Context, _ ScenarioFilter) ([]Scenario, error) {
return nil, nil
}
func (s *stubCatalog) MatchScenario(_ context.Context, _ uuid.UUID) (*Scenario, error) {
return nil, ErrUnknownScenario
}
// noOpHolidays never adjusts dates — the test fixture doesn't care about
// weekends or holidays, only about which base date the engine resolves.
type noOpHolidays struct{}
func (noOpHolidays) IsNonWorkingDay(_ time.Time, _, _ string) bool { return false }
func (noOpHolidays) AdjustForNonWorkingDays(d time.Time, _, _ string) (time.Time, time.Time, bool) {
return d, d, false
}
func (noOpHolidays) AdjustForNonWorkingDaysBackward(d time.Time, _, _ string) (time.Time, time.Time, bool) {
return d, d, false
}
func (noOpHolidays) AdjustForNonWorkingDaysWithReason(d time.Time, _, _ string) (time.Time, time.Time, bool, *AdjustmentReason) {
return d, d, false, nil
}
type fixedCourts struct{}
func (fixedCourts) CountryRegime(_, _, _ string) (string, string, error) {
return CountryDE, RegimeUPC, nil
}
func TestCalculate_BeforeChildOfCourtSetParent_OutOfOrderSequence(t *testing.T) {
ctx := context.Background()
// proceeding metadata
jurisdiction := "UPC"
procID := 1
pt := ProceedingType{
ID: procID,
Code: "upc.inf.cfi",
Name: "Verletzungsverfahren",
NameEN: "Infringement",
Jurisdiction: &jurisdiction,
IsActive: true,
}
mkID := func() uuid.UUID {
id, _ := uuid.NewRandom()
return id
}
str := func(s string) *string { return &s }
procIDPtr := &procID
socID := mkID()
oralID := mkID()
transID := mkID()
interpID := mkID()
socCode := "upc.inf.cfi.soc"
oralCode := "upc.inf.cfi.oral"
transCode := "upc.inf.cfi.translation_request"
interpCode := "upc.inf.cfi.interpreter_cost"
rules := []Rule{
{
ID: socID,
ProceedingTypeID: procIDPtr,
ParentID: nil,
SubmissionCode: &socCode,
Name: "Klageerhebung",
NameEN: "Statement of Claim",
PrimaryParty: str("claimant"),
DurationValue: 0,
DurationUnit: "months",
Timing: str("after"),
SequenceOrder: 0,
IsCourtSet: false,
IsActive: true,
LifecycleState: "published",
Priority: "mandatory",
},
// Translation request: sequence_order BEFORE the oral hearing.
// Reproduces the real corpus ordering (DB rows 45 < 50).
{
ID: transID,
ProceedingTypeID: procIDPtr,
ParentID: &oralID,
SubmissionCode: &transCode,
Name: "Antrag auf Simultanübersetzung",
NameEN: "Translation request",
PrimaryParty: str("both"),
DurationValue: 1,
DurationUnit: "months",
Timing: str("before"),
SequenceOrder: 45,
IsCourtSet: false,
IsActive: true,
LifecycleState: "published",
Priority: "optional",
},
// Interpreter cost notice: sequence_order BEFORE the oral hearing.
{
ID: interpID,
ProceedingTypeID: procIDPtr,
ParentID: &oralID,
SubmissionCode: &interpCode,
Name: "Mitteilung Dolmetscherkosten",
NameEN: "Interpreter cost notice",
PrimaryParty: str("court"),
DurationValue: 2,
DurationUnit: "weeks",
Timing: str("before"),
SequenceOrder: 46,
IsCourtSet: false,
IsActive: true,
LifecycleState: "published",
Priority: "mandatory",
},
// Oral hearing: court-set, no calculable date. Listed AFTER its
// "before"-timed children in sequence_order.
{
ID: oralID,
ProceedingTypeID: procIDPtr,
ParentID: nil,
SubmissionCode: &oralCode,
Name: "Mündliche Verhandlung",
NameEN: "Oral hearing",
PrimaryParty: str("court"),
DurationValue: 0,
DurationUnit: "months",
Timing: str("after"),
SequenceOrder: 50,
IsCourtSet: true,
IsActive: true,
LifecycleState: "published",
Priority: "mandatory",
},
}
cat := &stubCatalog{pt: pt, rules: rules}
// IncludeOptional=true because translation_request carries
// priority='optional'; the test exercises the before-child-of-
// court-set-parent flow, which is orthogonal to the optional-rule
// suppression added in t-paliad-342.
timeline, err := Calculate(ctx, "upc.inf.cfi", "2026-05-26", CalcOptions{IncludeOptional: true}, cat, noOpHolidays{}, fixedCourts{})
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("Calculate: %v", err)
}
byCode := make(map[string]TimelineEntry, len(timeline.Deadlines))
for _, d := range timeline.Deadlines {
byCode[d.Code] = d
}
// The trigger event itself is unambiguous.
if got := byCode[socCode]; got.DueDate != "2026-05-26" || !got.IsRootEvent {
t.Errorf("SoC: DueDate=%q IsRootEvent=%v, want 2026-05-26 + IsRootEvent=true", got.DueDate, got.IsRootEvent)
}
// Oral hearing must surface as IsCourtSet (no date).
oral := byCode[oralCode]
if oral.DueDate != "" || !oral.IsCourtSet {
t.Errorf("oral: DueDate=%q IsCourtSet=%v, want empty + IsCourtSet=true", oral.DueDate, oral.IsCourtSet)
}
// The two "before" children of the court-set oral hearing MUST surface
// as conditional rows (no date, no fabricated arithmetic off the
// trigger date). The buggy behaviour produces 2026-04-27 and 2026-05-12.
trans := byCode[transCode]
if trans.DueDate != "" {
t.Errorf("translation_request: DueDate=%q, want empty (parent oral is court-set, no anchor known yet)", trans.DueDate)
}
if !trans.IsConditional && !trans.IsCourtSet {
t.Errorf("translation_request: IsConditional=%v IsCourtSet=%v, want at least one true", trans.IsConditional, trans.IsCourtSet)
}
interp := byCode[interpCode]
if interp.DueDate != "" {
t.Errorf("interpreter_cost: DueDate=%q, want empty (parent oral is court-set, no anchor known yet)", interp.DueDate)
}
if !interp.IsConditional && !interp.IsCourtSet {
t.Errorf("interpreter_cost: IsConditional=%v IsCourtSet=%v, want at least one true", interp.IsConditional, interp.IsCourtSet)
}
}
// TestCalculate_BeforeChildOfCourtSetParent_WithOverride pins the
// override semantics: when the user supplies an anchor override for
// the court-set parent, the "before" children should compute against
// that override date instead of remaining conditional.
func TestCalculate_BeforeChildOfCourtSetParent_WithOverride(t *testing.T) {
ctx := context.Background()
jurisdiction := "UPC"
procID := 1
pt := ProceedingType{
ID: procID,
Code: "upc.inf.cfi",
Name: "Verletzungsverfahren",
Jurisdiction: &jurisdiction,
IsActive: true,
}
mkID := func() uuid.UUID {
id, _ := uuid.NewRandom()
return id
}
str := func(s string) *string { return &s }
procIDPtr := &procID
socID := mkID()
oralID := mkID()
transID := mkID()
socCode := "upc.inf.cfi.soc"
oralCode := "upc.inf.cfi.oral"
transCode := "upc.inf.cfi.translation_request"
rules := []Rule{
{
ID: socID, ProceedingTypeID: procIDPtr, ParentID: nil,
SubmissionCode: &socCode, Name: "Klageerhebung", NameEN: "SoC",
PrimaryParty: str("claimant"), DurationValue: 0, DurationUnit: "months", Timing: str("after"),
SequenceOrder: 0, IsActive: true, LifecycleState: "published", Priority: "mandatory",
},
{
ID: transID, ProceedingTypeID: procIDPtr, ParentID: &oralID,
SubmissionCode: &transCode, Name: "Antrag auf Simultanübersetzung", NameEN: "Translation request",
PrimaryParty: str("both"), DurationValue: 1, DurationUnit: "months", Timing: str("before"),
SequenceOrder: 45, IsActive: true, LifecycleState: "published", Priority: "optional",
},
{
ID: oralID, ProceedingTypeID: procIDPtr, ParentID: nil,
SubmissionCode: &oralCode, Name: "Mündliche Verhandlung", NameEN: "Oral hearing",
PrimaryParty: str("court"), DurationValue: 0, DurationUnit: "months", Timing: str("after"),
SequenceOrder: 50, IsCourtSet: true, IsActive: true, LifecycleState: "published", Priority: "mandatory",
},
}
cat := &stubCatalog{pt: pt, rules: rules}
// User pins the oral hearing to 2026-10-15. IncludeOptional=true
// because translation_request is priority='optional' (t-paliad-342).
opts := CalcOptions{
IncludeOptional: true,
AnchorOverrides: map[string]string{
oralCode: "2026-10-15",
},
}
timeline, err := Calculate(ctx, "upc.inf.cfi", "2026-05-26", opts, cat, noOpHolidays{}, fixedCourts{})
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("Calculate: %v", err)
}
byCode := make(map[string]TimelineEntry, len(timeline.Deadlines))
for _, d := range timeline.Deadlines {
byCode[d.Code] = d
}
if got := byCode[oralCode].DueDate; got != "2026-10-15" {
t.Errorf("oral: DueDate=%q, want 2026-10-15 (user override)", got)
}
// 1 month before 2026-10-15 = 2026-09-15
if got := byCode[transCode].DueDate; got != "2026-09-15" {
t.Errorf("translation_request: DueDate=%q, want 2026-09-15 (1 month before oral override)", got)
}
}